Doctor Who and the Sontaran Experiment


“Fishpond”“Fishpond”

Doctor Who and the Sontaran Experiment


BOOK DETAILS

Pages 96
ISBN 0-426-20049-7
Publication Date 7 December 1978

SYNOPSIS

Landing on Earth, now a barren, desolate planet, Sarah, Harry and the Fourth Doctor are unaware of the large, watching robot. The robot is the work of Styre, a Sontaran warrior, who uses all humans landing here for his experimental programmes.

What has happened to the other space explorers who have come here?

Why is the Sontaran scout so interested in Earth and is brutally torturing humans, including Sarah Jane? Will The Doctor, be able to prevent an invasion and certain disaster, and save both Earth and his companions?

NOTES

CHAPTER TITLES

  1. Stranded
  2. Unknown Enemies
  3. Capture
  4. The Experiment
  5. Mistaken Identities
  6. The Challenge
  7. Duel to the Death
  8. A Surprise and a Triumph


DEVIATIONS FROM THE TELEVISED STORY

  • Unlike the televised story, in which Fourth Doctor, Sarah, and Harry use Space Station Nerva’s transmat to come down to Earth, they come down in the TARDIS, which is then accidentally returned to Nerva by the transmat.
  • Nerva is consistently referred to by Fourth Doctor and other characters as”Terra Nova”.
  • Despite being called Styre on the back cover, within the text the Sontaran refers to himself as Sontaran Military Assessor Styr.
  • After falling down a hole, Fourth Doctor has a dream about rats chewing their way into the TARDIS.
  • Harry initially believes the Sontaran to be a Golem.
  • Sarah destroys one of the patrol robots with the Fourth Doctor’s sonic screwdriver. Much of Erak and Krans’ parts are exchanged, making Krans the more aggressive character. (He is described as big and burly, whereas on screen he is below average height.)
  • The Doctor falls down the crevice when the Scavenger lassoes Sarah and Roth while they are lowering him with his scarf.
  • Zake dies when the Scavenger stops him short with a lasso and causes him to break his neck, rather than falling down a crevice.
  • Styr is referred to several times as having an inky black breath.
  • Styr’s experiment on Sarah is more elaborate, with her hallucinating drowning, being burned alive in a desert and attacked by a horde of ants. She is imprisoned in a cave rather than tied to a rock, and when Harry enters the cave he is affected too, imagining himself being attacked by a demonic Sarah. The experiment has already begun when Harry first finds her.
  • There is an extra scene of the Doctormeeting Harry and finding out about the Sontarans before going off to find Sarah. (A version of this was scripted but apparently not filmed.) The Doctor is briefly trapped in the force-field at the cave mouth.
  • Styr’s superior is referred to as the Controller rather than the Marshal. It is revealed that Styr is delaying submitting his report because he is enjoying the experiments.
  • On screen, Roth refers to two GalSec crewmen killed in the experiments as Heath and Splear. Here, both Roth and Krans refer to Warra and Henk instead.
  • The Doctor and Styr start their fight unarmed and both later use the gravity bar as a weapon.
  • Styr kills Vural by knocking him over a cliff edge rather than stabbing him. He then throws The Doctor off the edge but he survives because part of the Scavenger’s levitation system slows his fall.
  • The Doctor weakens Styr during the fight by pouring the contents of a hip-flask into his probic vent.
  • The Doctor speculates that the Sontarans are trying to occupy Earth for its terullian deposits formed by the solar flares and later discovers it is part of an alliance with another cloned race, the Hyperioi. There is no mention of the war with the Rutan as on screen.

  • error: Content is protected
    Skip to content